A Bleak Holiday Season for Barnes & Noble

Dave Huntoon

The 2015 Christmas season turned out to be a challenging time for many retailers in the U.S.  Online sales continued to grow, while brick-and-mortar sales were disappointing for many operators.  One retailer under particular stress this year is Barnes & Noble.  The pressures facing them are well documented – the ongoing, relentless impact from Amazon, the decline in CD and DVD/Blu-ray sales, and the (somewhat surprising) resurgence of the independent bookstore as a competitor. Each of these is described further below:

Amazon – e-commerce has proven to be a very receptive environment for book sales.  While books are currently a small proportion of Amazon’s overall business (well under 10%), they are in many ways the face of Amazon.  The primary drawbacks of online bookstore sales are the lack of immediate gratification (albeit next-day delivery works for many people), and the inability to browse. Barnes & Noble has their own e-commerce site, but it is an also-ran compared with Amazon.  They have a challenging dilemma with in-store inventory as well – cutting back on inventory reduces carrying costs, but also increases the likelihood that a book customer will decide to abandon brick-and-mortar stores entirely.

Non-Book Sales – CDs and DVDs have traditionally been the largest merchandise categories for Barnes & Noble after books.  However, both of these categories have been hard hit in their own right: CDs by iTunes and other digital purveyors, and DVDs by Netflix and others.  As such, Barnes & Noble has scrambled to find suitable alternatives.  While shopping at Barnes & Noble the week before Christmas, I was stunned to see drones being marketed at the front desk.  Drones?  What do drones have to do with books?

Independent Bookstores – the number of independent bookstores has increased over the past five years (a 27% increase from 2009 – 2014).  This by no means suggests that book retailing will soon emulate local craft beers as the strongest growing segment of the market – much of the demand for independent bookstores has arisen from the demise of Borders and the fact that Barnes & Noble has closed many stores.  However, the ability of independent bookstores to cater to reader’s needs and desires while providing a more personal touch not available in large chain operations has also contributed to their growth.  Independents are often symbiotic with one another – in our hometown of Ann Arbor, the most recent independent bookstore to locate downtown (Literati) works to encourage their brethren by de-emphasizing mysteries (carried by Aunt Agatha’s) and graphic novels (carried by Vault of Midnight).

    Sign up for our newsletter by filling out the form below.

    Contact Form

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

    Related News